loading icon

What makes a strong, compelling cover? How do you effectively retain the specific elements and central essence that help make the original what it is without simply remaking it? Simple, ask Paranoid Image because their cover of Apparat's "Goodbye" strikes this balance extremely well indeed. Possessing the haunting, melancholic tone...

Music Critic Andre Avanessian

During the COVID lockdown, Sara and Christopher became obsessed with watching Dark, a German time travel series on Netflix. Even as the series became more confusing and weird through the seasons, they never missed watching the intro to each episode where the song "Goodbye" would play with a beautiful, artistic background related to the episodes. "Goodbye" is our acoustic adaptation of that song.

Staying true to PI's acoustic style, every note is performed by one of our instrumentalists, reminiscent, in ways, of the mostly electronic original. The scratching, plucking and harmonic thumping at the beginning is all performed on banjo, for example. In the middle of the song, a very deep, "backwards" surdo keeps the driving bottom. For the first time, we are introducing our string quintet into the mix. Enjoy!

Musicians

Sara Geller:
Vocals
Christopher Malone:
Piano, Double Bass, Composer, Orchestrator
Elizabeth Nelles:
Banjo
Em Moratto:
Acoustic Guitar
Al Buffone:
Surdo, Shakers, Cymbal
Other Exceptional Musicians & Artists
Olivia Shaw:
1st & 2nd Violin
Laurie Michelle:
Viola
Brendan O'Donoghue:
Cello
Cover Art Artist

Details

Release Date:
April 7, 2023
ISRC:
QZES92390820
Format:
Digital
Mixing:
Brian Hunter, Christopher Malone
Mastering:
Brian Hunter
Location:
The Mousetrap Recording Studio & Sawtelle Recording Studio at Swallow Hill | Denver CO
Indie Label:
StinkiMinki Productions
Copyright:
Groovylixir Productions LLC

Full Review

What makes a strong, compelling cover? How do you effectively retain the specific elements and central essence that help make the original what it is without simply remaking it? Simple, ask Paranoid Image because their cover of Apparat's "Goodbye" strikes this balance extremely well indeed.

Possessing the haunting, melancholic tone of the original whilst effectively translating its style of ambient electronica to a folk-inspired, more alternative sound, Paranoid Image has done a deeply commendable job of taking an existing piece of music, melding it into something new, and injecting their own distinct creative style and flavors into the mix in order to create an interpretation that manages to not only respect the original source material but confidently stand on its own two feet. Combining sweeping string layers, ambiance-inducing textures, tenderly conveyed banjo moments, and absorbing heartfelt vocals, Paranoid Image's version of "Goodbye" makes for a particularly enveloping listening experience that is both emotionally raw and beautifully expressed.

Strongest Point(s):
Both atmosphere and ambiance are integral components in the original "Apparat" and Paranoid Image has absolutely nailed this, albeit in their own unique way. Effectively replacing the predominately synth-based textures of the original with the more lush, emotion-steeped nature of richly layered strings, Paranoid Image has fleshed out the instrumentation in a way that really helps further draw out the emotional nuance of the writing and their effective timbral layering helps create a particularly rich soundscape that is both alluring and absorbing. There's a certain rawness in both the performances and the general style of the mix that I believe works extremely well and the live-performance feel certainly helps inject a certain spontaneity and grittiness into the way both the performances and writing come across to the listener that help heighten its emotional impact tenfold.

Target Audience Appeal:
"Goodbye" is a strong cover in the alternative/folk style and I can certainly see it strongly appealing to fans of these genres.

Music Critic Andre Avanessian